๐ŸŒ More incidents in the South China Sea


๐ŸŒ More incidents in the South China Sea

Plus: COP's draft stocktake released

Hi Intriguer. Years ago, I went along to a meeting with Xu Hong, the top lawyer in Chinaโ€™s foreign ministry (who later ended up as Chinaโ€™s ambassador to The Hague).

In those days, there was still hope that disputes in the South China Sea were legal issues that could be resolved in the comfort of a boardroom.

Todayโ€™s briefing (on the latest maritime clashes between China and the Philippines) shows just how much things have changed. Water cannons are now doing much more of the talking.

– Jeremy Dicker, Managing Editor

TODAYโ€™S NEWS

A second checkpoint. Israel says it will open a second screening checkpoint to increase aid into Gaza, where a visiting UN official has said โ€œmeaningful humanitarian operation is impossibleโ€. The move comes hours before a UN General Assembly vote on a non-binding resolution calling for an immediate ceasefire.

Xi in Vietnam. Xi Jinping has arrived in Vietnam today (Tuesday) to announce several joint projects, including a new rail link. Itโ€™s Xiโ€™s first trip to neighbouring Vietnam in six years, and we wouldnโ€™t be surprised if his travel plans were hurried along by President Bidenโ€™s visit to Vietnam in September.

Not playing games. A San Francisco court has ruled in favour of video games developer Epic Games (youโ€™ve got them to thank for Fortnite) in its suit against Google. A jury unanimously found that Google (which plans to appeal) is engaging in anti-competitive conduct, a result that could change the basics of how app stores operate.

MINUSMA ends. The 10-year UN peacekeeping mission to Mali officially came to an end yesterday after the Malian military junta declared it a โ€œfailureโ€ in June and ordered it to leave. The UN had previously cited human rights violations by the junta and its Russian supporters, the mercenary Wagner group.

TOP STORY

The Chinese Coast Guard clashed with Philippines fisherman near Scarborough Shoal last weekend. Map credit: The Print

Philippines summons Chinaโ€™s ambassador over latest South China Sea clashesย 

The Philippines has summoned Chinaโ€™s ambassador after two more incidents between Chinese and Philippines vessels near Scarborough Shoal and the Spratly Islands in the South China Sea last weekend.ย 

Manila says China used water cannons and long-range acoustic devices to disrupt the resupply of Philippines fishermen, then deployed similar tactics against a civilian resupply mission to a small outpost of marines.

For its part, Beijing says the Philippines โ€œgravely violated Chinaโ€™s sovereigntyโ€, and its own response was โ€œprofessional, restrained, justified and legitimateโ€.

Why are they fighting over this patch of water?

In 2009, China lodged a map with the UN displaying its now-famous โ€˜nine-dash lineโ€™, claiming โ€œhistorical rightsโ€ to ~90% of the South China Sea.

Various neighbours objected, and the Philippines took the matter to a court in The Hague, which found in 2016 that Chinaโ€™s line had โ€œno legal basisโ€. China responded by saying it โ€œneither accepts nor recognizesโ€ the courtโ€™s ruling.

And despite President Xiโ€™s assurances, heโ€™s continued to build military bases in places like Mischief Reef: 1,110km from China, but widely seen as falling within the 370km exclusive economic zone of the Philippines (240km away).

So the Philippines has sought to assert its rights, and China has responded with:

  • Military grade lasers to temporarily blind Philippines crews

  • Planting a floating barrier to block Philippines vessels from passing

  • Swarming reefs with over 100 vessels, and

  • Using water cannons in August, November, and this past weekend.

In response, Manila is now openly questioning the โ€œsincerity of [Chinaโ€™s] calls for peaceful dialogueโ€, while President Marcos Jr says Chinaโ€™s actions โ€œhave only further steeled our determination to defend and protect our nation's sovereigntyโ€.

INTRIGUEโ€™S TAKE

Chinaโ€™s President Xi Jinping probably has a few objectives driving his strategy in the South China Sea right now. He wants to:

  • Expand Chinaโ€™s sense of security by subduing its periphery

  • Control maritime trade routes that are key to Chinaโ€™s economy

  • Exert control over the seaโ€™s fishing and energy resources, and

  • Test US commitment to its allies like the Philippines.

And Xi is pursuing this strategy with:

  • โ€˜Grey-zoneโ€™ tactics like water cannons, to avoid crossing the threshold into acts of war, and

  • โ€˜Salami-slicingโ€™ tactics of gradual expansion, to craft an image of restraint while casting responses from others as escalation.

So what are the regionโ€™s options here?

The US could potentially declare the waters to fall within its defence treaty with the Philippines, but a similar 2014 move in support of Japan doesnโ€™t seem to have shaped Chinaโ€™s approach.

President Marcos Jr is doubling down on his alliance with the US, while seeking support from friends like Japan and Australia to bolster deterrence.

But the weekendโ€™s events suggest this isnโ€™t having much impact either.

Also worth noting:ย 

  • The Chief of Staff of the Philippines military was aboard one of the ships targeted by Chinaโ€™s water cannons over the weekend.

SUPPORTED BY URSA NOVA

Shop Sustainably This Season with Ursa Nova

This holiday season, experience the delight of guilt-free shopping with Ursa Nova, your premier destination for sustainable products. Our mission is to enhance your lifestyle with an exciting selection of curated brands and products that are good for both you and the planet. Choose thoughtful and sustainable presents for you and your loved ones and join a community dedicated to conscious living.

International Intrigue readers will receive a 10% discount* with promo code "Intrigue" on their first order.

Celebrate this holiday season with Ursa Nova and make this Christmas Green!

Ursa Nova, For A Better Planet & A Better You.

*Exclusions apply

๐ŸŒฑ COP28 CORNER

Delegates at COP28 have released a draft text of the first-ever global stocktake to assess humanityโ€™s progress on climate issues. The draft calls for a reduction in fossil fuel use โ€œin a just, orderly and equitable mannerโ€ rather than a full โ€œphase-outโ€ of fossil fuels, as some had hoped.ย 

Thereโ€™ve been some colourful responses from around the world:ย 

  • โ€œThe text as it now stands is disappointing. It is insufficient and not adequate to address the problem we are here to tackle. The science is clear: we need to phase out fossil fuels.โ€ EU climate chief Wopke Hoekstra

  • โ€œWe can live with this text as long as we leave here with an understanding that this means a massive investment in renewable energy in developing countries.โ€ Barbados Prime Minister Mia Mottleyย 

  • โ€œCOP28 is now on the verge of complete failure. The world desperately needs to phase out fossil fuels as quickly as possible, but this obsequious draft reads as if OPEC dictated it word for word.โ€Former US Vice President Al Gore

  • โ€œThe Marshall Islands did not come here to sign our death warrant. We came here to fight for 1.5C and for the only way to achieve that: a fossil fuel phase-out." – Marshall Islands rep John Silk

MEANWHILE, ELSEWHEREโ€ฆ

  1. ๐Ÿ‡ฐ๐Ÿ‡ทย South Korea: President Yoon Suk Yeol travelled to the Netherlands yesterday (Monday) for talks about a potential โ€œchip allianceโ€. South Korea is a top semiconductor manufacturer, while The Netherlands leads the world in chip-making equipment.ย 

  2. ๐Ÿ‡ต๐Ÿ‡ฑย Poland: Parliament elected former EU Council President Donald Tusk as prime minister last night after weeks of political wrangling. The centrist has pledged a more pro-EU stance, prompting an angry opposition leader to accuse him of being โ€œa German agentโ€.

  3. ๐Ÿ‡ฆ๐Ÿ‡บย Australia: Canberra has announced plans to halve immigration within two years. The policy is aimed at reducing pressure on housing and infrastructure, after a record 510,000 people moved to Australia in the twelve months to June 2023.

  4. ๐Ÿ‡จ๐Ÿ‡บย Cuba: Local authorities claim to have thwarted a terrorist attack by a Florida man who arrived on the island via jet-ski. The arrest came after Cuba published a list of alleged terrorists, including a candidate for mayor of Florida's Miami-Dade County.

  5. ๐Ÿ‡ฐ๐Ÿ‡ชย Kenya: Millions of Kenyans suddenly found themselves without power on Sunday after the third national blackout in three months. Officials are investigating if the outages are being caused by sabotage.ย 

EXTRA INTRIGUE

Hereโ€™s what folks around the world tweeted about yesterday

  • โ€‹๐Ÿ‡ฌ๐Ÿ‡ช Georgians were tweeting about Russian opposition figure โ€œAlexei Navalnyโ€, who has reportedly gone missing from a Russian prison.

  • ๐Ÿ‡ฎ๐Ÿ‡ฉ #TikTok was trending in Indonesia after the social media giant managed to circumvent Indonesiaโ€™s strict e-commerce regulations by purchasing a local company.

  • ๐Ÿ‡ธ๐Ÿ‡ชย And Swedes were talking about the Swedish-born EU diplomat โ€œJohan Floderusโ€, who was formally charged with espionage by an Iranian court on Sunday and could face the death penalty.

MAP OF THE DAY

Weโ€™ll bring you the equivalent womenโ€™s map soon

Menโ€™s sporting championships are distributed fairly evenly around the world and are mostly predictable: Australia reigns supreme in cricket, South Africa in rugby, Argentina in soccer, and Canada in ice hockey. Germany is the only listed country currently holding two titles, having won the field hockey world championship in January, and beating the US favourites to win the basketball title in September.

We would just note the above map doesnโ€™t reflect the fact that a British doctor won last weekโ€™s World Mullet Championships in Australia.

Yesterdayโ€™s poll: If you could travel back in time to spend a week with an ancient civilisation, where would you go?

๐ŸŸฉ๐ŸŸฉ๐ŸŸฉ๐ŸŸฉ๐ŸŸฉ๐ŸŸฉ ๐Ÿ—ก๏ธ Ancient Rome (38%)

๐ŸŸจโฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธ ๐Ÿ›ถ The Vikings (9%)

๐ŸŸจ๐ŸŸจ๐ŸŸจโฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธ ๐ŸŒด Ancient Egypt (18%)

โฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธ ๐Ÿ‘‘ The Ashanti empire (3%)

๐ŸŸจโฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธ ๐ŸŒต The Aztecs (11%)

โฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธ ๐ŸŽ The Mongols (3%)

โฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธ โ˜€๏ธ The Mughal empire (4%)

โฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธ ๐Ÿ‰ China's Song or Tang dynasties (5%)

๐ŸŸจโฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธโฌœ๏ธ โœ๏ธ Other (write in!) (9%)

Your two cents:

  • ๐ŸŒตย A.R: โ€œTheir lasting influence on the culture of the Americas is unquestionable.โ€

  • ๐Ÿ‰ย H.F: โ€œChina was the center for trade back then. Jade, pottery, silk, etc. Would be fascinating to experience the gateway of the Silk Road.โ€

  • ๐Ÿ—ก๏ธ J.L: โ€œtoga….toga….toga !! :)โ€