Italy weighs the pros and cons of China’s BRI


Briefly: Italy is the only member of the G7 (a club of seven wealthy nations) currently involved in China’s flagship Belt and Road Initiative (BRI – a trillion dollar global infrastructure program). But there are reports Italy may quit.

Rome has until the end of the year to make a call before Italy’s BRI membership renews automatically, much like that streaming subscription you keep forgetting to cancel.

Why’d Italy join the BRI in the first place?

  • 📉 It was feeling the effects of a debt crisis at the time (2019)
  • 🏗️ This made it tough for Rome to invest in much-needed infrastructure, and
  • 🤝 The government of the day saw China’s BRI as the solution

So why’s it now thinking of leaving?

  • 🤷 The BRI hasn’t really delivered on the promise of new infrastructure
  • 😨 Public attitudes towards China have shifted, and
  • ☟ Rome has faced pressure from the US and EU to re-think the BRI

Intrigue’s take: Despite best efforts to find a middle ground, the world always seems to find a way to force a choice: in this case, Italy can either keep China happy (by sticking with the BRI) or keep the West happy (by ditching the BRI).

Given the BRI’s limited results in Italy, Rome’s decision really comes down to what message it wants to send. And that in turn depends on what costs it’s willing to absorb. It’ll be well aware of China’s willingness to impose economic costs on countries that don’t play ball.

Also worth noting:

  • Estimates vary, but one recent Shanghai-based study says China has invested about $1T across the 148 BRI member states since 2013.
  • Before becoming prime minister last year, Meloni said it was “a big mistake” for Italy to join the BRI.
Latest Author Articles
What our leaders fear most

The World Economic Forum (WEF) crams epic wealth and power into the tiny Swiss ski resort of Davos each January, leaving it open to some truly cracking conspiracy theories — personally as Simpsons fans, we love to imagine Davos rigging every Oscars night. But we’ve been to Davos before (and will be back again from Monday), […]

17 January, 2025
The new rules that could upend AI

Just when you think Joe Biden is wrapping things up, he announces updated export controls on AI chips that’ve sent US tech giants into a tizzy.  Let’s dive in.  The new rules, sexily named the Regulatory Framework for the Responsible Diffusion of Advanced Artificial Intelligence Technology 💘, divide countries into three categories:  Stay on top of your world from inside your […]

15 January, 2025
Why China wants you to buy a new microwave

As clickbaity as it sounds, we’re not making the above title up.  On Wednesday, China’s policymakers announced they’ve added all sorts of small electronic appliances — microwaves, rice cookers, water purifiers — to a list of consumer products eligible for a subsidised trade-in. We’re not here to dunk on that idea — the US and others have […]

10 January, 2025
Why’s everyone talking about Greenland? 

When a quiet and distant land suddenly starts popping up on the front pages of international newspapers, it’s often one of three things: i) it’s won a sporting tournament, ii) there’s been some sort of disaster, or iii) someone important is talking about it. Greenland now falls into category three, though Trump critics might suggest […]

8 January, 2025