The world is arguing over deep-sea mining


Diplomats are today (Monday) meeting at the International Seabed Authority (ISA) in Jamaica, debating how to handle deep-sea mining in international waters. The marathon talks will run for three weeks.

Deep-sea mining is a nascent industry that involves ships hoovering potato-sized ‘nodules’ of metal off the seabed via 4km hoses.

Why are countries debating this industry now?

  • 🏝️ In 2021, the tiny nation of Nauru used an arcane rule to oblige the ISA to finalise deep-sea mining regulations within two years, but
  • ⏲️ That deadline expired yesterday (Sunday) without agreed rules, so the ISA’s 168 members are now debating what to do next.

And it’s unleashed a fair bit of tension. Supporters of deep-sea mining say:

  • ⚡ The sector is essential to supplying the key metals needed for our energy transition, to help address climate change
  • 👷 It’s a way for small nations to generate jobs and income, and
  • 🇨🇳 It can reduce the world’s over-reliance on China’s metals sector.

Opponents of deep-sea mining say:

  • 🐟 It’ll put a vast and little-understood ecosystem at risk
  • ⛏️ There are already enough proven metal deposits on land, and
  • 🔋 The tech sector is phasing out some of these metals anyway.

Intrigue’s take: We don’t envy the delegates tasked with finding a way forward here. The issues are genuinely tricky.

And things are getting heated: Germany has accused the ISA boss of pro-mining bias; others are querying whether a pause (as proposed by Chile) is legal; and there’s talk of referring the whole debate to an international court.

Still, the world has managed to ink treaties for other frontiers, like the 1967 Outer Space Treaty and the 1959 Antarctic Treaty. So, surely we can do it again in the deep blue.

Also worth noting:

  • Mining companies need a country sponsor to apply for ISA permits. Nauru works closely with The Metals Company, a Vancouver-based start-up which aims to start deep-sea mining next year.
  • Various major companies – like Google, BMW, Volvo, and Samsung – have committed not to use deep-sea metals in their products.
  • Norwegian lawmakers moved last month to greenlight deep-sea mining projects in the country’s exclusive economic zone.
Latest Author Articles
The Israel-Iran War: 6 lessons so far

Things have only escalated since Friday’s war briefing, with… So as these two old foes continue to trade blows and casualties, we’ve reflected on the six different lessons the world might now be learning: The ayatollah has spent decades dropping brash military diss tracks, only to get pantsed by Israel in a single night via […]

16 June, 2025
Why Uganda is having a meltdown over Germany’s ambassador

Uganda’s military announced on Sunday it’s cutting all ties with Germany! Why? Now, that is an incredibly spicy allegation to make against a foreign ambassador. In fact, we’d go so far as to liken it to the Merciless Pepper of Quetzlzacatenango. So what exactly did ol’ Mathias get up to? Well, the generals won’t say, though the head of the armed forces […]

27 May, 2025
Why the US just lost its AAA credit rating

Any action movie must include a scene where the lead strolls towards camera and doesn’t even flinch as the building in the background explodes into the sky. And 116-year old ratings agency Moody’s kinda did that on Friday, strolling towards the weekend while its grenade exploded with news that it was downgrading US debt from AAA to […]

19 May, 2025
A US-China trade truce

The top economic representatives of the US (Scott Bessent) and China (He Lifeng) just emerged from a weekend of talks at the Swiss ambassador’s UN residence on Lake Geneva, and announced they’ll lower tariffs and de-escalate their trade war. In practice, this means trade between the world’s two biggest economies is once again viable, though […]

14 May, 2025